Tradition

Aristotelianism

4th century BC, revived repeatedly

That politics is the study of how human beings live well together, that the city exists by nature, and that the best constitution is the one a given people can actually sustain.

Aristotle is the ancestor of political science as an empirical discipline and of virtue ethics as a moral one, and the two are connected. He held that the polis exists by nature because human beings are political animals, creatures who realize what they are only in a shared life under law. A person outside the city is either a beast or a god.

His method was to look first. He and his school collected the constitutions of 158 cities before generalizing, and the Politics reads as comparative government rather than as an ideal blueprint. That is the break with his teacher. Where the Republic asks what the best city would be, Aristotle asks which constitution suits which people, and answers that the most durable is polity, a mixture of oligarchy and democracy resting on a large middle class with enough property to be independent and not enough to despise their neighbors.

He also supplied the vocabulary that political argument still runs on: distributive justice as proportion rather than equality, the distinction between ruling for the common good and ruling for oneself, deliberation as the activity proper to citizens, and the claim that law should govern because law is reason without passion. Not all of it survives inspection. His defense of natural slavery is an argument he could have refuted with his own tools, and his account of women is worse.

The afterlife is enormous. The Arabic commentators made him the Philosopher; Averroes earned the title of Commentator; Aquinas Christianized the whole apparatus and made it the spine of scholastic politics. Every subsequent revival of virtue, the common good, or the political nature of human beings is a return to this text.

Lineage

Descends from

  • Greek Philosophy6th to 4th century BC

    Aristotle spent twenty years in Plato's Academy and defined his own position against it, keeping the conviction that the good life is a subject for argument and rejecting the claim that it is known by a separate expertise.

Gave rise to

  • Classical Islamic Political Philosophy9th to 12th century

    Falsafa is Aristotle read in Arabic. Averroes wrote commentaries so thorough that Latin readers called him simply the Commentator.

  • Classical Republicanism5th century BC to 2nd century AD

    The mixed constitution, the citizen who rules and is ruled in turn, and the middle class as the guarantor of stability are all from the Politics.

  • CommunitarianismLate 20th century to present

    MacIntyre and Sandel revived the claim that the self is constituted by its attachments and that politics concerns the good life, both straight from Aristotle.

  • Comparative Politics18th century to present

    The method begins with the collection of 158 constitutions: describe what exists, classify it, and generalize afterward.

  • Scholasticism12th-15th century

    The recovery of Aristotle through Arabic and then Latin translation reorganized the schools around him; Aquinas wrote commentaries on the Politics and the Ethics as well as the Summa.

  • ObjectivismMid-20th century to present

    Rand named Aristotle as the only philosopher she owed anything to, taking the logic, the ethics of flourishing and the confidence that reality is knowable.

Thinkers3
Related through shared thinkers5