Tradition

Scottish Enlightenment

18th century

The 18th century intellectual movement centered in Edinburgh and Glasgow that produced some of the most important philosophical work of its era.

The Scottish Enlightenment centered on Edinburgh, Glasgow and Aberdeen, and produced from a small and recently impoverished country an outsized share of modern moral philosophy, economics and social theory.

Its distinctive starting point was sociability. Hobbes had begun from isolated individuals calculating advantage. Francis Hutcheson argued instead for a moral sense as native to human beings as sight, and Hume and Smith built on it. Hume grounded morality in sentiment corrected by general points of view. Smith, in The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759), derived the whole of ethics from sympathy and the internalized judgment of an impartial spectator. His economics is downstream of that moral psychology and not separate from it, which is why reading the Wealth of Nations without it produces a caricature.

The Scots also invented a way of thinking about history. Conjectural or stadial history, in Smith, Ferguson, Kames and Millar, explained institutions as products of successive modes of subsistence instead of legislation or national character, which made law, property and manners into things with a developmental explanation. Ferguson supplied the movement's most quoted line, that establishments arise which are the result of human action but not of human design. Thomas Reid meanwhile mounted the common-sense reply to Hume's skepticism that dominated Anglo-American philosophy for a century.

Its influence traveled unusually well: through the American founders, through nineteenth-century political economy, and through Hayek, who took the anti-rationalist strand as the foundation of his own work. Modern scholarship has been mainly occupied with recovering how much the movement's celebrated commercial optimism was qualified by its own authors, Smith on the stupefying effects of the division of labor and Ferguson on what commercial society does to civic virtue.

Lineage

Descends from

  • Empiricism17th-18th century

    Hume's account of knowledge and convention is empiricism carried into moral and political theory.

  • Natural LawAncient to present

    Hutcheson held the Glasgow chair in the natural-jurisprudence tradition and Smith succeeded to it; the Lectures on Jurisprudence are the hinge between natural law and political economy.

Gave rise to

  • Civil Society18th century to present

    Adam Ferguson named the concept, and supplied the formulation that establishments arise which are the result of human action but not of human design.

  • Classical Liberalism17th-19th century

    Hume on convention and Smith on the unintended coordination of self-interested action gave the tradition its social theory.

  • Political Economy18th century to present

    Smith, Hume and Ferguson made the wealth of nations a subject, and treated it as inseparable from law, manners and the form of government.

  • Spontaneous Order18th century to present

    Ferguson's formulation is the tradition's classic statement; Menger and Hayek made it an analytical framework.

Thinkers9
Thinker

Adam Smith

1723–1790

Adam Smith was the Scottish Enlightenment moral philosopher who founded modern liberal political economy and grounded markets in human sympathy rather than selfishness

Thinker

David Hume

1711–1776

David Hume was a Scottish Enlightenment philosopher whose skeptical empiricism grounded politics in custom and sentiment, pairing conservative respect for institutions with liberal gradualism

Thinker

Francis Hutcheson

1694–1746

The Glasgow professor who argued that moral judgment runs through an innate sense rather than a calculation, coined the greatest-happiness formula, and taught Adam Smith.

Thinker

Henry Home, Lord Kames

1696–1782

The judge who treated law as a historical product rather than a deduction, sketched the four-stage theory of social development, and served as patron to half the Scottish Enlightenment.

Thinker

Thomas Reid

1710–1796

The founder of common-sense philosophy, who answered Hume by rejecting the premise both empiricists and rationalists had shared: that the mind perceives ideas rather than things.

Thinker

Adam Ferguson

1723–1816

Chaplain to the Black Watch turned Edinburgh professor, whose Essay on the History of Civil Society gave the phrase its modern meaning and stated the principle of unintended order.

Thinker

William Robertson

1721–1793

Principal of Edinburgh University and leader of the Moderate party in the Kirk, who wrote history as the study of how societies change rather than how princes behave.

Thinker

John Millar

1735–1801

Smith's student and Glasgow's professor of civil law, who explained rank, authority and the position of women as products of the mode of subsistence rather than of nature.

Thinker

Dugald Stewart

1753–1828

The Edinburgh professor who transmitted the Scottish Enlightenment to the nineteenth century, teaching a generation of Whig politicians, editors and economists — James Mill among them.

Defining tradition for1
Related through shared thinkers5