Tradition

Civil Society

18th century to present

The intellectual tradition that emphasizes the importance of voluntary associations, local institutions, and intermediate groups standing between the individual and the state.

Civil society is the tradition that puts voluntary associations, local institutions and intermediate groups at the center of political life. Clubs, congregations, unions, mutual societies and professional bodies stand between the individual and the state, and free politics depends on them.

The Scottish Enlightenment named the concept, in Adam Ferguson's Essay on the History of Civil Society (1767), and two very different thinkers gave it its modern shape. Hegel identified civil society as a distinct sphere between family and state, the realm of particular interest that the state must integrate. Tocqueville, observing America in the 1830s, argued that a democratic people prevented from associating would be defenseless before both centralized power and majority opinion, and that forming associations is a skill which has to be practiced to survive.

Gramsci then inverted the picture from the left. Civil society is not a bulwark against domination but the terrain on which ruling groups secure consent, the schools, churches and press through which hegemony is maintained instead of imposed. The two readings have coexisted uneasily ever since: civil society as the guarantor of pluralism, and civil society as the machinery by which existing arrangements reproduce themselves.

The term acquired new force in Central Europe before 1989, where dissidents used it to describe an autonomous social life built deliberately outside the party-state, and again in Putnam's work on social capital and the decline of associational membership. Its current critics argue that the concept has been stretched past usefulness. Professionalized NGOs are not what Tocqueville described; well-organized associational life can be sectarian or violent as easily as civic; and treating association as intrinsically democratic ignores what many associations are actually for.

Lineage

Descends from

  • RepublicanismAncient to present

    The claim that self-government depends on associations standing between citizen and state is republican before it is sociological; Tocqueville read America through it.

  • Scottish Enlightenment18th century

    Adam Ferguson named the concept, and supplied the formulation that establishments arise which are the result of human action but not of human design.

Gave rise to

  • CommunitarianismLate 20th century to present

    The communitarian revival took Tocqueville's associations as the answer to what liberal individualism had hollowed out.

Converges with

  • CommunitarianismLate 20th century to present

    Tocqueville's associations and MacIntyre's practices come from opposite directions — one an empirical account of what makes democracy work, the other a claim about what a moral life needs — and land on the same intermediate institutions.

Thinkers10
Thinker

Robert Nisbet

Robert Nisbet was a conservative American sociologist who argued that the modern state's growth hollowed out the communities and mediating institutions on which liberty depends

Thinker

Saul Alinsky

1909–1972

Saul Alinsky was an American community organizer whose theory of grassroots power-building gave the modern progressive-activist tradition its playbook for confronting entrenched institutions.

Thinker

Václav Havel

1936–2011

Václav Havel was a Czech dissident playwright turned president who argued that authentic political life begins with ordinary people refusing to live within an official lie.

Thinker

Jane Addams

1860–1935

Jane Addams was an American reformer who built the settlement house into a laboratory for democratic social action and made peace activism a matter of political principle.

Thinker

Adam Ferguson

1723–1816

Chaplain to the Black Watch turned Edinburgh professor, whose Essay on the History of Civil Society gave the phrase its modern meaning and stated the principle of unintended order.

Thinker

Elinor Ostrom

1933–2012

Elinor Ostrom was a political economist who showed that communities can govern shared resources themselves, defying the dogma that only states or markets can prevent ruin.

Thinker

Booker T. Washington

1856–1915

Booker T. Washington was the most powerful African American leader of his era, advocating economic self-improvement over political agitation while secretly funding legal challenges to segregation

Thinker

Peter Drucker

Peter Drucker was a pluralist social thinker, conservative in temperament yet reformist in aim, who sought a middle path between unregulated capitalism and state planning through decentralized, self-governing institutions

Thinker

Abraham Kuyper

1837–1920

Abraham Kuyper was a Dutch theologian and prime minister whose doctrine of sphere sovereignty shaped Christian democracy and gave religious conservatives a principled defense of civil society against state overreach.

Thinker

Alexis de Tocqueville

1805–1859

Alexis de Tocqueville was an aristocrat by birth and a liberal by conviction whose Democracy in America remains the most insightful analysis of democratic society ever written by an outsider

Voices today2 living

Living writers, politicians and public figures working in this tradition today. Association, not endorsement: a figure appears where their stated commitments place them, and is reachable by role and search like everyone else.

Defining tradition for1
Related through shared thinkers6