Conservative Haplotype Rarity: ~3% of population

Reform Conservative

You blend market economics with practical adaptation to modern realities. Conservative principles must evolve to remain relevant without abandoning core values.

Orientation: Policy innovation, family-focused, conservative modernization

Dimension Scores

Liberty
50
Markets
57
Global
50
Culture
45

Understanding This Type

Reform Conservatives believe the right needs new policy thinking to address 21st-century challenges while remaining true to conservative principles. Against both libertarian orthodoxy that ignores market failures and progressive statism that expands bureaucracy, they seek creative conservative solutions to problems like healthcare costs, family decline, and wage stagnation.

This strain emerged in the early 2010s through thinkers and politicians who saw the GOP trapped between unpopular libertarianism and reflexive opposition to everything. They argued conservatives needed an affirmative agenda addressing voters' actual concerns—not just tax cuts for the wealthy and deregulation, but policies that help working families and rebuild social capital.

Key Reform Conservative themes include: pro-family policy (child tax credits, paid leave, work-family balance), healthcare reform that reduces costs and expands access without single-payer, wage subsidies over minimum wage increases, education reform emphasizing skills and vocational training, and industrial policy to create good jobs in struggling regions.

Reform Conservatives occupy interesting terrain—they're more willing to use government than libertarians, more focused on working families than establishment Republicans, but more market-friendly than progressives. They've influenced policy discussions around child benefits, healthcare, and industrial policy, though their movement identity has somewhat merged into broader post-Trump realignments.

At roughly 3% of the population as a distinct type, Reform Conservatives are more an intellectual tendency than a mass movement. They're found in think tanks like American Compass, among younger conservative policy experts, and in the orbit of politicians trying to develop post-Reagan conservative policy. They bridge old-guard conservatism and new populism through policy innovation.

Dimension Analysis

Personal Liberty

50

Balanced on liberty—not libertarian but not authoritarian. Accept government intervention when it strengthens families and communities. Pragmatic about means; focused on whether policies achieve conservative ends.

  • Paid family leave through creative policy mechanisms
  • Childcare support that respects parental choice
  • Drug policy balancing enforcement with treatment
  • Privacy concerns balanced with security needs

Market Economy

57

Pro-market but willing to correct market failures. Support free enterprise while acknowledging markets don't automatically produce good jobs, affordable healthcare, or strong families. Open to industrial policy and targeted interventions.

  • Industrial policy to restore manufacturing and create good jobs
  • Healthcare reform using market mechanisms with universal coverage goal
  • Wage subsidies (EITC expansion) over minimum wage mandates
  • Child tax credits and family benefits as pro-family policy

Global Orientation

50

Moderate on globalism—neither full nationalist nor uncritical internationalist. Support trade with attention to losers, controlled immigration, and American engagement with realistic expectations.

  • Trade agreements should include support for displaced workers
  • Immigration policy balancing economic needs and integration
  • Industrial policy ensuring domestic capacity for key sectors
  • Engaged foreign policy without idealistic overreach

Cultural Values

45

Traditionally oriented but focused on policy support rather than culture war. Want government to strengthen families and communities through policy, not primarily through moral campaigns. Pragmatic on social issues.

  • Pro-family policy (benefits, tax code) over cultural crusading
  • Marriage promotion through economic stability
  • Education reform emphasizing vocational paths and skills
  • Support religious institutions through school choice and charitable incentives

Core Beliefs

  • Child tax credits and family policy are pro-family conservatism—supporting parents is conservative
  • Markets need updating for 21st century challenges—blind faith in deregulation isn't enough
  • Healthcare market isn't working—conservatives need actual solutions, not just opposition
  • Industrial policy to create good jobs is legitimate conservative governance
  • Working families need economic support, not just lectures about personal responsibility
  • Conservative principles require creative application to new circumstances

Internal Tensions

  • How much government intervention is acceptable before it's just progressivism?
  • Universal benefits vs. targeted programs for the truly needy
  • Market solutions vs. acknowledging some markets are fundamentally broken
  • Maintaining coalition with libertarians who oppose the whole project
  • Policy focus vs. culture war that energizes the base

Foundational Thinkers

Yuval Levin

AEI scholar on institutions and conservative reform

Ross Douthat

New York Times columnist on conservative renewal

Reihan Salam

Manhattan Institute president on immigration and class

Michael Brendan Dougherty

National Review writer on tradition and reform

Henry Olsen

Ethics & Public Policy Center fellow on elections

Contemporary Voices

Oren Cass

American Compass founder challenging free-market orthodoxy

Marco Rubio

Senator promoting common-good capitalism

Ramesh Ponnuru

National Review editor and reformicon

Josh Hawley

Senator challenging Big Tech and promoting worker policy

Julius Krein

American Affairs founder on industrial policy

Communities & Spaces

Reformicon Twitter X/Twitter

Policy innovation conservatives

American Compass readers Web

Worker-focused conservative audience

Conservative policy wonks Various

Think tank-adjacent discourse

National Review reformers Web

Intellectual renewal conservatives

R Street community Various

Market-oriented reform advocates

Key Institutions

American Compass

Oren Cass think tank on worker-focused conservatism

R Street Institute

Market-oriented reform conservatism

Niskanen Center

Moderate policy reform organization

American Enterprise Institute

Think tank with reformicon scholars

Ethics & Public Policy Center

Conservative policy with religious grounding

How It Compares

vs. Moderate Conservative (Overlapping but Distinct)

Aspect Reform Conservative Moderate Conservative
Policy Innovative/creative Traditional/cautious
Markets Correct failures Trust markets
Family Policy Active support Limited government
Working Class Policy focus Growth benefits all

vs. National Conservative (Policy Allies)

Aspect Reform Conservative National Conservative
Style Policy wonk Nationalist rhetoric
Trade Reform/support workers Protectionist
Immigration Moderate reform Dramatic reduction
Focus Policy innovation National identity

vs. Traditional Libertarian (Friendly Opponent)

Aspect Reform Conservative Traditional Libertarian
Government Tool for conservative ends Minimize always
Family Policy Active support Not government role
Industrial Policy Strategic necessity Market distortion
Healthcare Need solutions Free the market

Common Critiques

This is just progressivism in conservative clothing—more spending, more government
Conservatives have always supported some government functions. The question is what serves conservative goals: strong families, thriving communities, dignified work. Child tax credits that let parents raise children aren't progressive—they're profoundly conservative.
Markets work—government "help" always creates dependency and distortion
Tell that to communities devastated by trade and automation while government did nothing. Markets are tools, not gods. When markets produce healthcare that costs twice as much as other countries, or hollowed-out regions with no good jobs, conservative governance requires response.
You're just trying to outbid Democrats with benefits—that's a losing game
We're trying to design conservative alternatives to progressive programs that are popular because they address real needs. If conservatives only say "no" while families struggle, progressives win. We'd rather win with conservative solutions than lose with libertarian purity.
Policy wonkery doesn't win elections—Trump proved you need cultural energy
Trump won by promising to address working-class concerns—healthcare, jobs, trade. We're trying to develop policies that actually deliver. Cultural energy without policy substance produces one-term presidencies. The winning formula combines both.
This strain has failed—where are the actual policy victories?
The expanded child tax credit passed with bipartisan support (though temporarily). Criminal justice reform happened. These ideas are shaping debate. Policy change is slow, but reform conservative ideas have moved from fringe to mainstream in Republican policy discussions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Compassionate conservatism (George W. Bush) added social concern to traditional conservatism but largely accepted market orthodoxy. Reform conservatism is more willing to critique market outcomes and use policy intervention. It's more substantive on policy and less about tone/messaging.
It's more than acceptance—it's about designing conservative versions of social policy. Child benefits structured to support parental choice, healthcare reform that uses markets with universal coverage, wage subsidies that reward work. The goal is conservative means to conservative ends, not progressive policies with conservative branding.
Oren Cass (American Compass), Yuval Levin (National Affairs), Ross Douthat (New York Times), Reihan Salam (Manhattan Institute), and various economists and policy experts. Politicians like Marco Rubio, Josh Hawley, and J.D. Vance have adopted elements, though they mix it with other strains.
There's overlap on working-class concerns, industrial policy, and skepticism of libertarian orthodoxy. But Reform Conservatives are more policy-focused and less culturally combative. Some see their role as providing substantive policy for populist energy; others worry populism undermines serious governance.
Common priorities: expanded child tax credit, paid family leave (various mechanisms), healthcare reform with universal access through market mechanisms, wage subsidies and EITC expansion, industrial policy and reshoring, vocational education and apprenticeships, and place-based policies for struggling regions.

Is This Your Political DNA?

Take the Political DNA Scan to discover your type among 32 distinct political strains.

Take the Quiz →