Tradition

Christian Democracy

19th century to present

That politics should be ordered by Christian social teaching without becoming clerical — accepting democracy and the market, and binding both by the dignity of the person and the duties of solidarity.

Christian Democracy is the most electorally successful political tradition of postwar Europe and the least theorized, because it was built by people governing rather than by people writing.

Its doctrinal source is Catholic social teaching, above all Rerum Novarum (1891), which condemned both socialism and unrestrained capitalism and asserted a right to a living wage, to property, and to association. From it come the two concepts that do the tradition's work. Subsidiarity holds that decisions should be taken at the lowest competent level, with higher bodies assisting rather than absorbing lower ones — a doctrine that limits the state without leaving the individual alone against the market. Solidarity holds that society is a body of mutually obligated persons rather than a market of individuals, which licenses extensive welfare provision on grounds no liberal individualism supplies.

Maritain gave it a philosophy. Writing after the fall of France and the collaboration of much of the Catholic right, he argued that a Christian could and must embrace democracy and human rights, distinguishing the person — with an inviolable spiritual destiny — from the individual as a unit of society. He shaped the drafting of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

The politicians made it a governing order. De Gasperi in Italy, Adenauer in Germany and Schuman in France rebuilt shattered states on it, and the European Coal and Steel Community was substantially their project: Catholic, cross-border, and designed to make war between France and Germany materially impossible. In the Netherlands, Kuyper's Calvinist doctrine of sphere sovereignty had arrived at a strikingly similar structure from a Protestant direction.

Its long decline tracks European secularization, and its remnants are visible in the EU's founding vocabulary.

Lineage

Descends from

  • Catholic Political ThoughtMedieval to present

    Rerum Novarum (1891) supplied the doctrine: condemnation of both socialism and unrestrained capitalism, a right to a living wage and to association, and the principle of subsidiarity.

  • Distributism20th century to present

    The preference for widely spread property and for enterprise at the smallest workable scale carries over, minus the agrarian nostalgia.

  • Natural LawAncient to present

    The dignity of the person as a limit on what any majority may enact is a natural-law claim, and Maritain made the Thomist version the basis of his defense of human rights.

Formed against

  • Fascism20th century to present

    De Gasperi was imprisoned by Mussolini and Adenauer removed by the Nazis; the tradition was constituted by people whose alternative to authoritarianism had failed once already.

  • Marxism19th century to present

    Rerum Novarum condemned socialism by name, and postwar Christian Democracy was built as the electoral instrument against communist parties in Italy, France and Germany.

  • Classical Liberalism17th-19th century

    Against a market of individuals bound only by contract: solidarity holds that society is a body of mutually obligated persons, which licenses welfare on grounds liberal individualism does not supply.

Converges with

  • Ordoliberalism20th century to present

    The German social market economy is the two traditions in combination: Erhard's framework economics inside Adenauer's party, with Röpke and Rüstow supplying a social frame Catholic teaching already asked for.

Thinkers5
Related through shared thinkers1