Begin assessment
Tradition

Philosophy of History

18th century to present

The systematic philosophical attempt to understand history as a process with meaning and direction.

Does history have a shape, or is it one thing after another? The philosophy of history is the attempt to answer that, and to say what drives the shape if there is one.

Vico's New Science (1725) made the early modern case: human history is intelligible in a way nature is not, because humans made it. Herder added that peoples develop along their own internal logic and not down a single universal road. Hegel gave the tradition its most ambitious form, reading history as the progressive realization of freedom through successive conflicts of consciousness, and set the terms for nearly everything after. Marx kept the directional structure and moved its engine to material production. The twentieth-century cyclical theorists kept the ambition and dropped the progress: Spengler's Decline of the West (1918-22), Toynbee's comparative account of civilizations rising and collapsing.

Karl Popper delivered the most serious attack. The Poverty of Historicism (1957) argued that theories claiming to find laws of historical development cannot be falsified, and that they cannot in principle predict the growth of knowledge on which the future depends. His further point was political: such theories supply certainty to the people acting on them, and that is what makes the error dangerous rather than merely academic.

Fukuyama reopened the Hegelian question in 1989, arguing not that events would stop but that no rival to liberal democracy retained ideological legitimacy. Most readers have taken the three decades since as a refutation; he has maintained they misread the claim.

The field's standing difficulty is that its central question is unusually hard to test. The periods when a directional account of history feels most obviously true have tended to be the periods when it was most obviously local.

Lineage

Descends from

  • Enlightenment Philosophy18th century

    Voltaire coined philosophie de l'histoire and Condorcet gave it a direction; the Enlightenment made history a subject for explanation rather than chronicle.

Gave rise to

  • Nationalism18th century to present

    Herder's Volksgeist supplied nationalism with its central claim: that a people is a historical individual with a destiny of its own.

  • History of Ideas20th century to present

    It kept the object — the career of ideas across time — and abandoned the claim that they move in a direction, which is why Popper belongs to both the tradition and its refutation.

  • Romantic Political Thought18th-19th century

    Herder's account of peoples as historically formed wholes, each with its own genius, is the seed of Romantic politics.

Provoked a reaction in

  • History of Ideas20th century to present

    The Cambridge school's contextualism is a refusal of the directional, meaning-seeking histories that philosophy of history produced.

Thinkers17
Thinker

Ibn Khaldun

1332–1406

Ibn Khaldun was the North African jurist and historian who explained the rise and collapse of dynasties through group solidarity — a naturalistic science of society written four centuries before the discipline existed in Europe.

Thinker

José Ortega y Gasset

1883–1955

José Ortega y Gasset was a Spanish liberal philosopher whose Revolt of the Masses diagnosed civilization's gravest internal threat — the mass man who demands without contributing and mistakes comfort for achievement

Thinker

Augustine of Hippo

354–430

Augustine of Hippo was the Christian theologian of the two cities, whose City of God gave the West its most influential account of political authority as legitimate, necessary, and never ultimate

Thinker

Henry Home, Lord Kames

1696–1782

The judge who treated law as a historical product rather than a deduction, sketched the four-stage theory of social development, and served as patron to half the Scottish Enlightenment.

Thinker

William Robertson

1721–1793

Principal of Edinburgh University and leader of the Moderate party in the Kirk, who wrote history as the study of how societies change rather than how princes behave.

Thinker

Polybius

200–118 BCE

The Greek hostage in Rome who explained Roman success by its mixed constitution, and gave republicanism its theory of how balanced government resists decay.

Thinker

Thucydides

460–400 BCE

The Athenian general whose history of the Peloponnesian War founded the realist account of politics: that states act on interest and fear, and that justice enters only between equals.

Thinker

Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot

1727–1781

Controller-General who tried to reform France out of its crisis and was dismissed in twenty months, and who wrote the first clear statement of history as indefinite progress.

Thinker

Giambattista Vico

1668–1744

The Neapolitan who argued that we can know history because we made it, and that societies pass through recurring ages of gods, heroes and men.

Thinker

Johann Gottfried Herder

1744–1803

The pastor who argued that each people has its own irreducible way of being human, founding cultural nationalism and the case against a single standard of progress.

Thinker

Eric Voegelin

1901–1985

Eric Voegelin was an anti-totalitarian political philosopher who diagnosed Nazism and Communism as secular Gnosticisms — political religions trying to immanentize the eschaton and build heaven through politics

Thinker

Oswald Spengler

1880–1936

Oswald Spengler was the German prophet of civilizational decline whose Decline of the West cast democracy as a passing phase destined to yield to Caesarism — a framework that shaped twentieth-century political pessimism

Thinker

Karl Popper

1902–1994

Karl Popper was a liberal philosopher of science who turned falsifiability into a defense of the open society — arguing that democracies are superior not because they are just but because they can correct their mistakes

Thinker

Arthur Schopenhauer

1788–1860

Arthur Schopenhauer was a political quietist whose pessimistic philosophy of blind will challenged Enlightenment rationalism and shaped Nietzsche, Freud, and the counter-Enlightenment tradition

Thinker

John Dewey

1859–1952

John Dewey was a pragmatist philosopher of democratic liberalism whose ideas shaped progressive education, democratic theory, and American liberal thought throughout the 20th century

Thinker

G.W.F. Hegel

1770–1831

G.W.F. Hegel was a German idealist philosopher who saw the modern constitutional state as the highest realization of freedom — a dialectical vision claimed by Marxists, conservatives, and liberals alike

Thinker

Antonio Gramsci

1891–1937

Antonio Gramsci was an Italian revolutionary Marxist whose concept of cultural hegemony transformed how the left — and, unexpectedly, the right — understands the manufacture of consent in modern societies

Related through shared thinkers6
Archetype

National Conservative

4 shared thinkers

Archetype

Traditionalist

4 shared thinkers

Archetype

Independent Localist

3 shared thinkers

Archetype

Moderate Conservative

3 shared thinkers

Archetype

Pragmatic Centrist

3 shared thinkers

Archetype

Social Liberal

3 shared thinkers

Back to traditions