Conservative Haplotype Rarity: ~3.5% of population

National Conservative

You prioritize national sovereignty, traditional values, and cultural preservation while supporting free enterprise. Globalism threatens both prosperity and identity.

Orientation: National sovereignty, cultural preservation, America First

Dimension Scores

Liberty
48
Markets
57
Global
28
Culture
38

Understanding This Type

National Conservatives represent a resurgent strand of right-wing politics that prioritizes the nation—its sovereignty, borders, culture, and citizens—over abstract principles of free markets or universal values. They argue that the conservative movement lost its way by embracing globalist economics and interventionist foreign policy while neglecting the communities and traditions that actually sustain human flourishing.

This strain emerged as a self-conscious movement in the late 2010s, crystallized by conferences organized by the Edmund Burke Foundation and intellectuals like Yoram Hazony. But its roots run deeper: to the paleoconservative tradition of Pat Buchanan, the "Middle American Radicals" identified by Sam Francis, and ultimately to a pre-Cold War conservatism that prioritized nation over ideology.

National Conservatives critique both libertarian economics and neoconservative foreign policy. They argue free trade hollowed out American manufacturing, open immigration depressed wages and eroded social cohesion, and democracy promotion abroad wasted blood and treasure while neglecting problems at home. "America First" isn't just a slogan—it's a genuine reorientation of priorities.

Culturally, National Conservatives emphasize the particular over the universal. They see nations as natural units with distinct characters worth preserving. Mass immigration isn't just an economic issue but a cultural one: rapid demographic change disrupts the intergenerational transmission of traditions, values, and identity that conservatives believe essential to social flourishing.

At roughly 3.5% of the population, National Conservatives punch above their weight through influence in the Trump-era Republican Party and adjacent media. They've shifted GOP positions on trade, immigration, and foreign policy significantly rightward and more nationalist. Critics see them as nativists or ethno-nationalists; supporters see them as returning conservatism to its proper focus on concrete communities rather than abstract ideologies.

Dimension Analysis

Personal Liberty

48

Moderately restrictive on personal liberty—National Conservatives accept state power in service of national interests and traditional morality. They're less libertarian than mainstream conservatives, more willing to use government for conservative cultural ends.

  • Support immigration enforcement including deportation and border walls
  • Comfortable with tariffs and industrial policy despite market distortions
  • Accept social media regulation to counter perceived liberal bias
  • Support traditional morality in public policy, less libertarian on social issues

Market Economy

57

Pro-market but with significant nationalist caveats. Support free enterprise domestically while rejecting free trade orthodoxy. Willing to use tariffs, industrial policy, and regulation to protect American workers and industries from foreign competition.

  • Tariffs on China and other competitors to protect American manufacturing
  • Industrial policy to ensure domestic production of strategic goods
  • Skeptical of Wall Street and multinational corporations' loyalty to America
  • Support for American workers over cheap labor and consumer prices

Global Orientation

28

Strongly nationalist—this is the defining feature. Skeptical of international institutions, trade agreements, immigration, and foreign entanglements. Sovereignty and self-determination trump global cooperation.

  • Dramatic reduction in legal and illegal immigration
  • Withdrawal from or renegotiation of trade deals (NAFTA → USMCA)
  • Skepticism of NATO, UN, and other international commitments
  • End to democracy promotion and nation-building abroad

Cultural Values

38

Culturally conservative with emphasis on preservation of national character. See rapid social change and demographic transformation as threats to continuity. Value tradition, religion, and national identity over cosmopolitan progressivism.

  • Immigration policy should consider cultural compatibility
  • English as official language, American civic culture as standard
  • Skeptical of multiculturalism as ideology (versus diversity as fact)
  • Traditional family and religious values as foundation of social order

Core Beliefs

  • Nations are natural human communities—diversity works between countries, not necessarily within them
  • Mass immigration threatens wages, social cohesion, and cultural continuity
  • Global institutions like the UN, WTO, and EU undermine democratic sovereignty
  • Free trade benefited multinationals and China while devastating American communities
  • Conservative elites betrayed their voters by prioritizing ideology over their interests
  • Foreign policy should serve American interests, not spread democracy or maintain "liberal world order"

Internal Tensions

  • Economic nationalism vs. traditional conservative free-market principles
  • Religious universalism vs. national particularism
  • Populist style vs. intellectual respectability
  • Alliance with libertarians who share some enemies but not priorities
  • How much state power is acceptable in service of conservative ends

Foundational Thinkers

Yoram Hazony

Israeli philosopher, author of The Virtue of Nationalism

Patrick Deneen

Notre Dame professor, author of Why Liberalism Failed

Harry Jaffa

Claremont founder and Lincoln scholar (1918-2015)

Leo Strauss

Political philosopher influential on neoconservatism (1899-1973)

Samuel Huntington

Harvard political scientist on civilizational conflict (1927-2008)

Contemporary Voices

J.D. Vance

Senator and Vice President, Hillbilly Elegy author

Laura Ingraham

Fox News host promoting national conservatism

Blake Masters

Tech executive turned nationalist politician

Christopher Rufo

Anti-CRT activist and Manhattan Institute fellow

Vivek Ramaswamy

Entrepreneur and 2024 presidential candidate

Communities & Spaces

r/Conservative Reddit

Mainstream Republican Reddit base

MAGA Twitter X/Twitter

Trump movement coalition

American Greatness readers Web

Intellectual natcon audience

Claremont Review readers Web

West Coast Straussian discourse

Telegram nationalist channels Telegram

Right-wing organizing

Key Institutions

Edmund Burke Foundation

Organizes National Conservatism conferences worldwide

Claremont Institute

West Coast Straussian think tank aligned with New Right

Heritage Foundation

Conservative policy organization behind Project 2025

American Compass

Oren Cass think tank challenging free-market orthodoxy

Center for Renewing America

America First policy organization

How It Compares

vs. Moderate Conservative (Establishment Rival)

Aspect National Conservative Moderate Conservative
Trade Protectionist Free trade
Immigration Dramatic reduction Moderate reform
Foreign Policy America First Internationalist
Corporations Skeptical Generally allied

vs. Traditional Libertarian (Uneasy Ally)

Aspect National Conservative Traditional Libertarian
Immigration Restrict heavily Restrict (different reasons)
Trade Tariffs acceptable Tariffs acceptable
State Power Use it conservatively Minimize it
Foreign Policy Non-interventionist Non-interventionist

vs. National Populist (Close Ally)

Aspect National Conservative National Populist
Style Intellectual Populist
Economics Pro-market with caveats More interventionist
Institutions Capture and reform Burn it down
Rhetoric Burke, Hazony Trump, Tucker

Common Critiques

National Conservatism is just a polite wrapper for white nationalism and xenophobia
National Conservatives include people of all backgrounds who believe in American nationhood. Civic nationalism—based on shared values, language, and loyalty—is not ethnic nationalism. Concerns about immigration rates and cultural assimilation are legitimate policy debates, not racism.
Protectionism and industrial policy are failed policies that hurt consumers
Free trade theory assumes adjustment costs are temporary and gains are shared. In reality, American communities were devastated while gains flowed to shareholders and China. Some economic efficiency is worth sacrificing for national resilience, good jobs, and social stability.
Abandoning international alliances and institutions weakens America
The question is whether these institutions serve American interests. NATO allies free-ride on American defense spending. Trade agreements shipped jobs overseas. The UN lectures America while coddling dictatorships. Alliances should be transactional, not theological.
This is just nostalgia for a past that never existed or that excluded many Americans
National Conservatives aren't trying to restore the 1950s. They're arguing that nations, borders, and particular cultures matter—that rootless globalism isn't the only path to modernity. Many immigrant communities share these values and are welcome partners in national renewal.
Using state power for conservative ends will backfire when progressives control the state
The state is already being used for progressive ends—through schools, bureaucracies, and corporate capture. Unilateral disarmament isn't noble; it's surrender. The question is whether conservatives will fight on the battlefield that exists or the one they wish existed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Traditional post-Cold War conservatism fused free markets, traditional values, and strong defense/democracy promotion. National Conservatism breaks from free trade orthodoxy, opposes immigration more strongly, rejects democracy promotion abroad, and is more willing to use state power for conservative ends. It prioritizes the nation over abstract principles.
Related but distinct. Nationalism is a broader orientation; National Conservatism is a specific intellectual movement trying to articulate nationalist principles within conservative thought. Populism is a style; National Conservatism overlaps with populist movements but is more focused on ideas and institutions than anti-elite rhetoric alone.
Dramatic reduction in both legal and illegal immigration. Secure borders, end chain migration, eliminate diversity visa lottery, merit-based selection for reduced numbers, mandatory E-Verify, and serious interior enforcement. The goal is a pause allowing assimilation and protecting American workers.
National Conservatives support free enterprise domestically but reject globalist free trade ideology. They argue markets should serve the nation, not the reverse. This means accepting tariffs, industrial policy, and regulation when necessary to protect American workers, industries, and national security.
Yoram Hazony (The Virtue of Nationalism), Patrick Deneen (Why Liberalism Failed), Oren Cass (economic policy), J.D. Vance (now Senator), and various writers at American Affairs, Compact, and American Conservative. The Edmund Burke Foundation organizes major conferences bringing this coalition together.

Is This Your Political DNA?

Take the Political DNA Scan to discover your type among 32 distinct political strains.

Take the Quiz →