Judith Shklar
Thinker

Judith Shklar

1928–1992 · Latvian-American · philosopher

Judith Shklar was a postwar liberal political theorist whose “liberalism of fear” grounded liberalism not in abstract rights but in avoiding cruelty and preventing the worst abuses of power

Judith Shklar (1928–1992) was a political theorist who spent most of her career at Harvard University, where she became one of the most influential thinkers in postwar liberal political philosophy. Born in Riga, Latvia, into a Jewish family that fled the twin threats of Nazism and Stalinism, her early experience of exile and displacement deeply informed her later preoccupation with fear, cruelty, and the vulnerability of ordinary people to abuses of power. She was among the first women to hold a senior position in Harvard's government department, and she trained a generation of political theorists.

Shklar is best known for articulating what she called the "liberalism of fear." Rather than founding liberalism on a positive vision of human flourishing, natural rights, or a comprehensive moral doctrine, she argued that liberalism should begin from a negative starting point: the avoidance of cruelty and the systematic prevention of the worst that human beings do to one another. In her account, cruelty—the deliberate infliction of physical and emotional pain—is "the summum malum," the first among vices, and the constant reality of fear that cruelty produces is what a decent political order must guard against. This made her liberalism minimalist and hard-headed rather than utopian: its aim was to secure a space of dignity and safety by limiting concentrations of power and protecting individuals from official terror.

Her thought drew on a close, often skeptical reading of the political and moral traditions, and she wrote extensively on figures such as Montesquieu and Rousseau, as well as on the passions and vices that shape political life, including studies of injustice, hypocrisy, betrayal, and the felt experience of being wronged. She insisted that political theory attend to the perspective of victims and to ordinary sense of injustice rather than only to tidy philosophical definitions of justice.

Shklar's influence has been substantial and enduring. Her emphasis on cruelty, fear, and the abuse of power offered an alternative to both rights-based and welfare-based liberal traditions, and it shaped the work of later thinkers, including her students, who developed themes of judgment, memory, and the moral seriousness of politics. Her insistence that liberalism take evil and suffering seriously, without lapsing into grand metaphysical claims, remains a touchstone for debates about the foundations and purposes of liberal politics.

Major works3
  1. Legalism1964

    Criticized the legal profession's self-image, arguing that treating law as sealed off from politics is itself a political stance.

  2. Ordinary Vices1984

    Put cruelty first among the vices, and built from that the liberalism of fear — a politics organized around avoiding the worst.

  3. The Faces of Injustice1990

    Distinguished injustice from misfortune, and asked why victims are so often told their suffering was nobody's doing.

Traditions2
Archetypes1
Influences & connections6

A selection of notable, documented connections — not an exhaustive map.

Intellectual lineage

  • Charles de Montesquieu

    The analyst of despotism whose account of fear as the animating principle of tyrannical rule gave Shklar the historical core of her 'liberalism of fear'; she devoted her 1987 study 'Montesquieu' to reclaiming him.

  • G.W.F. Hegel

    His phenomenology of consciousness and history anchored Shklar's 'Freedom and Independence' (1976); wrestling with Hegel's system taught her to read political thought as the record of concrete moral experience.

  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau

    The subject of her 1969 'Men and Citizens: A Study of Rousseau's Social Theory'; his diagnosis of inequality, dependence, and psychological cruelty sharpened Shklar's attention to how social power wounds ordinary people.

  • Thomas Hobbes

    Made fear of violent death the foundation of political order; Shklar took over his insistence that fear comes first while rejecting his absolutism, turning Hobbesian fear into a liberal guard against cruelty and state terror.