Nationalist Haplotype Rarity: ~7% of population

National Populist

You champion the common people against both global elites and cultural change. Immigration and free trade hurt working families while elites profit.

Orientation: Anti-elite, economic nationalism, America First populism

Dimension Scores

Liberty
50
Markets
55
Global
33
Culture
48

Understanding This Type

National Populists champion ordinary people against a self-serving elite that they believe has rigged the economy and sold out the country. They see both political parties as captured by donors and special interests—Wall Street, Silicon Valley, multinational corporations—that profit from policies hurting working Americans: trade deals that ship jobs overseas, immigration that undercuts wages, and endless wars that sacrifice American lives for unclear gains.

This strain surged with Donald Trump's 2016 campaign, which broke from Republican orthodoxy on trade, immigration, and foreign policy while speaking directly to working-class frustrations. But the roots run deeper: to Ross Perot's anti-NAFTA campaigns, Pat Buchanan's "peasants with pitchforks," and a long American tradition of populist revolt against perceived elite betrayal.

The core conviction is that the system is rigged. Free trade agreements were sold as benefiting everyone but actually benefited corporations and China while devastating American manufacturing communities. Immigration, both legal and illegal, floods labor markets and changes communities without the consent of those affected. The "rules-based international order" extracts American resources to police the world while neglecting problems at home.

National Populists are neither conventionally left nor right on economics. They support entitlement programs like Social Security and Medicare that benefit working people. They're skeptical of corporate tax cuts that flow to shareholders. But they're also suspicious of means-tested welfare and programs they see as benefiting those who don't work or aren't American citizens.

At roughly 7% of the population, National Populists are a major political force—the core of Trump's base and a significant faction in the realigned Republican Party. They've fundamentally shifted GOP positions on trade, immigration, and foreign policy. Critics see them as nativist and authoritarian; supporters see them as finally giving voice to forgotten Americans.

Dimension Analysis

Personal Liberty

50

Moderate on personal liberty—National Populists value freedom but define it differently than libertarians. They support gun rights and property rights while accepting government action against perceived enemies: Big Tech censorship, illegal immigration, elite corruption.

  • Strong support for Second Amendment and gun rights
  • Skeptical of Big Tech—support regulation or breakup
  • Law and order: support police against perceived criminals
  • Government should work for Americans, not global interests

Market Economy

55

Mixed on economics—neither free-market purists nor socialists. Support tariffs and industrial policy to protect American jobs. Defend entitlements for working people while skeptical of welfare. Suspicious of both Wall Street and government bureaucracy.

  • Tariffs on China and outsourcers to protect American jobs
  • Protect Social Security and Medicare—Americans earned them
  • Skeptical of corporate tax cuts that benefit shareholders
  • Against spending on foreign aid and "globalist" projects

Global Orientation

33

Strongly nationalist—this is the defining feature. America First means prioritizing American citizens, borders, and interests over international commitments, alliances, and immigration. Skeptical of global institutions and agreements.

  • Secure the border and dramatically reduce immigration
  • End or renegotiate trade deals that hurt American workers
  • Withdraw from international commitments that don't serve America
  • Stop nation-building and endless wars abroad

Cultural Values

48

Moderate-to-traditional on culture—value American identity and traditions without being religiously motivated. Concerned about rapid cultural change, immigration changing communities, and elite contempt for ordinary Americans' values.

  • American culture and identity worth preserving
  • Immigration should assimilate to America, not change it
  • Tired of being called racist, sexist, deplorable by elites
  • Traditional values respected but not religious crusade

Core Beliefs

  • Elite consensus on trade and immigration has devastated working-class communities
  • Both parties serve donors, lobbyists, and global interests—not regular Americans
  • China trade policy destroyed American manufacturing while enriching corporations
  • Immigration—legal and illegal—undercuts wages and changes communities without consent
  • The "establishment" looks down on ordinary Americans while profiting from their suffering
  • America First isn't selfish—it's what every country's government should do for its people

Internal Tensions

  • Economic populism vs. Republican alliance with business interests
  • Anti-establishment rhetoric vs. supporting Trump and MAGA establishment
  • Working-class solidarity vs. cultural resentments that divide workers
  • Conspiracy thinking that identifies real problems vs. paranoid versions
  • Legitimate grievances vs. scapegoating immigrants and minorities

Foundational Thinkers

Patrick Buchanan

Paleoconservative who pioneered America First populism

James Burnham

Theorist of managerial revolution (1905-1987)

Christopher Caldwell

Author on immigration and Age of Entitlement

Michael Anton

Claremont fellow and Flight 93 Election author

Julius Evola

Traditionalist philosopher influential on far-right (1898-1974)

Contemporary Voices

Tucker Carlson

Media figure articulating economic nationalism

Steve Bannon

Trump strategist and populist nationalist ideologue

Stephen Miller

Immigration hardliner and Trump advisor

Nick Fuentes

America First streamer and Groyper movement leader

Charlie Kirk

Turning Point USA founder and youth organizer (1993-2025)

Communities & Spaces

MAGA Twitter X/Twitter

Trump movement base

Groyper Army X/Twitter/Cozy.tv

America First youth movement

Tucker Carlson audience Various

Economic nationalist viewers

Working-class conservative Facebook Facebook

Rust Belt politics

America First communities Telegram

Nationalist organizing

Key Institutions

America First Policy Institute

Trump-aligned policy organization

America First Political Action Conference (AFPAC)

Annual Groyper movement gathering

Center for Immigration Studies

Immigration restriction research

Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR)

Immigration reduction advocacy

Turning Point USA

Youth conservative populist organization

How It Compares

vs. National Conservative (Ideological Siblings)

Aspect National Populist National Conservative
Style Populist/combative Intellectual/refined
Focus Anti-elite anger National sovereignty
Economics Intuitive/mixed Theorized nationalist
Institutions Burn it down Capture and reform

vs. Moderate Conservative (Establishment Opponents)

Aspect National Populist Moderate Conservative
Trade Tariffs/protection Free trade
Immigration Dramatic restriction Moderate reform
Style Anti-establishment Establishment
Trump Core supporters Reluctant or opposed

vs. Welfare Nationalist (Nationalist Allies)

Aspect National Populist Welfare Nationalist
Welfare Earned benefits only Generous for citizens
Culture American identity Social cohesion focus
Economics Mixed/intuitive Social democratic
Tone Combative/angry Policy-focused

Common Critiques

National Populism is just racism and xenophobia dressed up as economic concern
Concerns about trade and immigration have real economic foundations—manufacturing job losses, wage stagnation, community disruption. Dismissing all populist concerns as bigotry is how elites avoid addressing legitimate grievances. Some supporters may have racist views; the core concerns are about economics and sovereignty.
Tariffs and trade wars hurt consumers and don't actually bring jobs back
The free trade consensus enriched shareholders and China while devastating American manufacturing towns. Some jobs have returned; more importantly, the goal is leverage and industrial capacity, not consumer prices alone. Americans are producers too, not just consumers.
You've been conned by a billionaire pretending to be a populist
Trump delivered on judicial appointments, border enforcement, trade renegotiation, and avoiding new wars—more than establishment Republicans ever did for working people. Perfect? No. Better than the alternative? We think so. Judge by results, not class background.
Populism leads to authoritarianism—you're undermining democratic norms
The "norms" protected a system rigged against ordinary people. If elites are above accountability, demanding accountability isn't authoritarian—it's democratic. The administrative state, media monopolies, and election systems needed challenging. We're not undermining democracy; we're trying to restore it.
Conspiracy theories about "elites" and "deep state" are paranoid and dangerous
That coordinated opposition from intelligence agencies, media, and bureaucracy tried to remove Trump isn't conspiracy theory—it's documented. That elites have different interests than working people isn't paranoid—it's obvious. Specific theories may go too far, but the basic insight is sound.

Frequently Asked Questions

Trump catalyzed and defined it, but the tendency predates him (Buchanan, Perot) and will outlast him. National Populism is an orientation: skepticism of elites and globalization, prioritizing nation and citizens, economically mixed but culturally rooted. Trump gave it a vehicle; it's not reducible to one person.
Neither neatly. They're conservative on immigration, crime, and cultural identity. They're not traditionally conservative on free markets and trade. They support entitlements but oppose welfare expansion. They've scrambled the old categories—that's part of their political power.
Border security (wall/barriers), interior enforcement (E-Verify, deportations), end to sanctuary policies, dramatic reduction in legal immigration, elimination of diversity visa lottery, shift to merit-based selection, and stopping chain migration. The goal is significant reduction and regaining control.
America First: no more endless wars, skepticism of NATO and alliances that don't serve American interests, opposition to nation-building, willingness to talk to adversaries while maintaining strength. Realist and transactional rather than idealistic or neoconservative.
The conditions that produced it—deindustrialization, wage stagnation, cultural dislocation, elite disconnection—haven't been resolved. Whether the specific movement lasts depends on leadership and events, but the underlying constituency will remain politically potent. Something like National Populism will persist.

Is This Your Political DNA?

Take the Political DNA Scan to discover your type among 32 distinct political strains.

Take the Quiz →